Saturday, November 28th, 2009 at
4:13 am
I am a healthy living guy, eat organic food, filter water, eat natural foods, hate diet chemical drinks, trans fats, msg, canned foods lines with BPA and so on and so on. Now why would I let my baby be breastfed by a mother who eats all of these things when I can give her Hipp Organic milk with filtered water. My GF did really well during pregnancy giving up smoking, drinking, eating fresh fruit, veg, and everything else I insisted on such as pure fish oils. As soon as pregnancy was over, she told me she couldnt keep it up. My question is did I do the right thing? I dont believe any intelligence difference can be proved to be just breast feeding, as the experiments are flawed. i.e A mother who breastfeeds is more likely to be more intelligent and therefore have a more intelligent baby. Also there is no proof that and IQ gap lasts into adulthood, as that is more dependant on good genes and education. i.e if your parents have a high IQ, You will have a high one regardless. So why really should I expose my baby to chemicals if I dont have to?
Incidentally I have added fish oil to the bottles, as Hipp dont have marine based DHA fats.
Dyot! ,
It is you who have not read my question. Just because experiments have proved better intelligence does not mean its down to breast feeding. of course breast feeding is better with a healthy diet, and so the mum who breastfeeds, is more likely to be educated, and more intelligent. Unless you can isolate the factors that made that kid intelligent, it doesnt mean that much. To the 1st person who called me a troll : - you have obviously not read my question. I asked is it always best taking into account a bad diet. Plse dont put stupid comments down. Its a good question and I would have loved my GF to breast feed if she didnt smoke.
All other comments very good. Obviously I want the best for my baby, and adding a little fish oil, was taking a little risk, but I was trying to make up at least a little after research into DHA
Dyot, Although that experiment included Thirteen potential confounders including smoking, there are so many possible factors that could go to make intelligence. Did any of the mothers eat good fats bad fats, drink, drink caffeine, take vitamins, eat carrots, have organic formular with added DHA….have mercury fillings, get the picture? It would be impossible to say what combinations make a minimal improvement in intelligence. Good Genes obviously have a far bigger impact. U havent really understood my question as well as some of the others. I was asking mostly about exposure to chemicals and did the advantages of breastfeeding outweight organic bottle food with added DHA. Granted I can see why u have answered me that way, but u would fail certainly our HSBC verbal reasoning test by not answering the question. Is it always better, taking into account the chemicals my girlfriend absorbs in her body. There are probably bottle fed people here who have understood the question correctly.
Technorati Tags: bpa, breast feeding, canned foods, do the right thing, filter water, filtered water, fish oil, fish oils, giving up smoking, good question, google, healthy diet, high iq, organic food, organic milk, script type, stupid comments, text javascript, trans fats, veg